About . . . . Classes . . . . Books . . . . Vita . . . . Blog. . . . Podcast

by Peter Moskos

April 25, 2008

"Hard" versus "soft" drugs

The Dutch make an interesting and useful distinction between "hard" and "soft" drugs. When a Amsterdam police officer says, "I think drugs should be illegal and dealers should go to prison," they're almost assuredly talking about "hard" drugs like crack and heroin. Marijuana and hashish are considered “soft” drugs and were decriminalized in 1976.

The result is that "coffee shops" selling weed and hash appeared, since people knew you wouldn't get arrested for possession.

When the hard/soft distinction was made, the idea was to accept marijuana for what it is and allow people to buy weed without having to deal with drug dealers and guns and gangsters.

The hard/soft distinction is somewhat arbitrary. But no more so than our distinctions between legal, prescription, and prohibited drugs.

There is also some debate about whether to classify ecstasy and hallucinogenic mushrooms as hard or soft.

Dutch police generally support the hard/soft distinction and would not want to close “coffee shops,” even if they could. In speech, they use “drug” to mean “hard drug.”

When I asked a police officer to clarify the distinction between "hard" and "soft" drugs, she said a hard drug is one that, "if you do it wrong, you can die." That's not a bad working definition. Particularly because it presents the problem of drug policy as geared to saving lives, and not imposing morals or punishing deviants.

Of course I think all drugs should be regulated, but I would settle for a system where no drug user is jailed, violence is low, and drug use is seen as a public-health rather than criminal-justice issue.


Anonymous said...

So I guess alcohol is a hard drug in Amsterdam, right? :-)

Peter, I'd be interested to hear your thoughts on the "safe injection site" initiative in Vancouver, BC. Super quick summary for anyone who doesn't know about it: Vancouver has a heroin problem, and a few years ago they established about four "safe" clinics downtown where people could go to shoot up. The clinics provide clean needles, and there was a nurse there in case something happened. Heroin isn't decriminalized, but clearly the police were on board.

ny rehab center said...

Discipline needs to be imposed on the region. This is to avoid further incidents.